Why Are We Always Preparing Children for Adulthood?
Childhood is often treated as preparation for the life that comes later. But what happens to the life a child is living now?
Childhood is one of the shortest periods of a person's life, yet so much of it is organized around the future. We worry about what children are learning, whether they're developing as they should, and whether the choices we're making now will prepare them for whatever comes later.
But children aren't only becoming adults. They're living a life now.
What might change if we took that life as seriously as the one we're preparing them for?
Prefer listening? This article was inspired by an episode of Radical Learning Talks about childhood, the expectations adults bring into it, and what it might mean to protect children's freedom to experience childhood on their own terms.
Listen to the episode here:
In this episode, we explore:
How expectations about development and the future can shape the way we relate to children
Why our own childhood experiences can influence how much freedom we're comfortable giving our kids
The difference between protecting children and projecting our fears onto them
What comparison, milestones, and social expectations can take away from the present
Why trusting children doesn't mean abandoning our responsibilities as adults
What it could mean to treat childhood as valuable in itself
We say childhood goes by too quickly. We tell parents to treasure it, to enjoy these years while they last, to remember that children are only little once.
And then we spend an extraordinary amount of that short time preparing them for what comes next.
It begins almost as soon as they arrive. We watch for milestones and track development. We think about whether they're getting enough stimulation, whether they're becoming independent, whether they're developing the skills they'll need later. As they grow, the questions change, but the direction rarely does. Are they learning enough? Are they responsible enough? Will they be able to manage on their own? Are they becoming ready for the world?
None of these concerns are difficult to understand. Children do grow up, and part of caring for them is thinking beyond the present moment. There are things we know that they don't yet know, dangers we can anticipate that they can't, and responsibilities that belong to us precisely because we are the adults.
But somewhere inside all that care, childhood often becomes a project we manage.
The child in front of us is always on their way somewhere. What they do today becomes significant because of what it might mean tomorrow. Their interests become skills to develop, their difficulties become problems to address, and their play can become another opportunity for learning. Even their freedom can be evaluated according to whether it is helping them become creative, resilient, independent adults.
It can be surprisingly difficult to let childhood have value without asking what it is producing.
When Childhood Becomes Preparation
This future orientation is built deeply into the way we think about children. We talk about preparing them for school, for secondary education, for university, for work, for independence, for the real world. Each stage seems to exist partly to prepare them for the next one.
Education makes this especially visible. A child rarely gets to learn something simply because it fascinates them without adults eventually wondering where it might lead. Reading matters because they'll need it later. Mathematics matters because they'll need it later. Persistence, organization, social skills, independence — all are framed as things children need to acquire so they'll be equipped for adulthood.
Of course they will need many of those things. The strange part is not that we think about the future. It's how easily the future becomes the lens through which we understand the present.
“The focus isn’t on ease and fun and natural development. It’s on outcome.”
A child who spends hours absorbed in something that doesn't look particularly useful can make adults uneasy. A child who isn't interested in something we've decided is important can make us even more uneasy. We know there is plenty of time for them to grow, and yet there is often an urgency underneath our response: if this isn't happening now, will it happen at all?
That urgency can make it difficult to see what is already happening.
A child balancing along a wall isn't necessarily practicing coordination. They may simply enjoy balancing along a wall. Someone climbing a tree may not be building resilience or learning to assess risk. They may be trying to reach a branch. A child who spends an afternoon making something that falls apart hasn't necessarily gained a useful lesson from failure.
Sometimes they were simply living their afternoon.
There is something revealing about how difficult it can be for adults to leave it there. We are so accustomed to translating children's experiences into development that even when we want to defend play, we often defend it by explaining everything children learn through playing. Play develops creativity. Risk develops judgment. Boredom develops initiative. Freedom develops independence.
All of that may be true. But notice what we've done.
We have made childhood justify itself through its future benefits again.
What Does a Childhood Need to Produce?
Perhaps this is part of what makes it so difficult to resist the pressure around milestones, achievement, and progress. The concern isn't always about what a child is experiencing now. Often it is about what we fear their present might mean for their future.
A child who isn't reading yet becomes a possible teenager who will struggle academically. A child who prefers being alone becomes an adult we worry won't know how to form relationships. The child who avoids challenge raises questions about resilience; the one who takes risks makes us wonder whether they'll ever learn to be careful.
The present begins to fill with imagined futures.
And because those futures feel consequential, intervening can feel like responsible parenting. We encourage, redirect, expose, stimulate, remind, and sometimes push. Not necessarily because anything is wrong right now, but because we are trying to prevent something from being wrong later.
There are real moments when children need adults to intervene. Protecting childhood doesn't mean pretending children possess information or capacities they don't have, nor does it require ignoring the actual conditions in which a family lives. A child growing up in a large city will encounter different freedoms and dangers from one growing up in a rural community. What is possible for one family may simply not be possible for another.
The question isn't whether adults should protect children. It's what happens when protection, preparation, and fear of the future begin taking up so much space that there is less room for children to have experiences that belong entirely to them.
Because childhood isn't only where adulthood comes from.
It is also a period of someone's life.
And perhaps those two truths — children are growing toward something, and they are already fully living — are harder for us to hold together than we realize.
The Fears We Bring With Us
Adults don't encounter childhood from some neutral position. We bring our own histories into it.
Some of us remember enormous freedom. Others remember very little of it. We may have grown up with adults who trusted us to wander, experiment, get dirty, make mistakes, and disappear into whatever absorbed us. Or we may have learned very early to be responsible, careful, productive, helpful, mature.
Those experiences don't disappear when we become parents. Neither do the expectations of the culture around us. They become part of what feels normal, what feels dangerous, what makes us uncomfortable, and what we believe a good parent is supposed to do.
This is one reason two adults can watch the same child doing the same thing and have completely different reactions. One sees exploration; another sees danger. One sees a child deeply absorbed in something they love; another wonders whether they should be doing something more productive. One sees a child who enjoys solitude; another starts worrying about social development.
Sometimes the concern belongs to what is actually happening. Children don't always understand the risks they're taking, and adults have information and experience they don't yet have. There are moments when stepping in is part of caring for them.
But there are also fears that arrive from somewhere else.
They come from remembering what happened to us, imagining what could happen to them, comparing them with other children, or wondering what other adults will think of the choices we're making. A child can be perfectly content in the present while the adult beside them is already living several years into their future.
That future can become remarkably persuasive.
It can convince us that something needs to change even when nothing is wrong yet.
When Our Worry Becomes Their Childhood
This is where the pressure surrounding childhood becomes difficult to separate from our own lives.
Parents are being watched too. There are expectations around what a competent child looks like, but there are also expectations around what competent parenting looks like. A child who behaves in ways other people recognize as successful can become reassurance that we are doing things right. A child who develops differently, wants something unusual, takes risks we wouldn't take, or simply refuses to cooperate with the expected timeline can expose us to other people's judgment.
That is an uncomfortable position to occupy.
And children can end up carrying some of that discomfort for us.
We may call it encouragement when we're trying to make their choices easier for other people to understand. We may call it concern when comparison has frightened us. We may believe we're helping them prepare for life when what we're really trying to do is make the uncertainty of their development easier for ourselves to bear.
None of this requires bad intentions. Much of it comes from love. We can interfere precisely because the stakes feel so high to us.
But the effect on childhood doesn't depend entirely on our intentions.
A child experiences the life we create around them. The reminders, the caution, the pressure, the opportunities we arrange, the things we don't allow, the things we insist are important. They live inside the decisions adults make while thinking about who they might become.
And that makes it worth asking how much of the future they should have to carry while they are still living the present.
“They will be adults for the rest of their lives, but they will never be kids again.”
Childhood Doesn't Need to Look One Way
There is a temptation, once we begin questioning how much we manage childhood, to replace one ideal with another.
The free childhood becomes a particular picture: children outdoors all day, roaming neighborhoods, climbing trees, building things, taking risks, coming home dirty. For some children, that may be glorious. For others, it wouldn't feel like freedom at all.
A child can spend hours reading indoors and be completely immersed in life. Another may need movement, noise, physical challenge, and other people around them. Some seek novelty constantly; others return to the same interests for years. Their environments, abilities, temperaments, cultures, families, and circumstances are different.
Protecting childhood can't mean producing the correct kind of childhood.
If there is something worth protecting, it may be the possibility for children to have a relationship with their own lives — to discover what draws them in, what they enjoy, what frightens them, what they're ready for, what they aren't, and how they want to spend some of this finite time.
Adults remain part of that life. We make decisions children cannot make. We hold responsibilities they should not have to carry. We sometimes have to say no because we can see something they cannot.
But being responsible for children is not the same as being the author of their childhood.
There has to be room for a life that isn't entirely organized around our purposes for it.
A Life Before Adulthood
Perhaps one reason this is difficult is that adulthood has become the destination against which childhood is measured.
We want children to emerge capable. Independent. Responsible. Able to navigate relationships, work, difficulty, uncertainty. We want them to have choices. We want them to be okay.
Those hopes aren't the problem.
The problem begins when the adult we hope they will become starts taking precedence over the person who is already here.
Because there is no moment when childhood stops being life and adulthood begins being life. There isn't a preliminary version followed by the real thing. The afternoon spent balancing on a wall, disappearing into a book, talking to a friend, making something, doing apparently nothing, or pursuing an interest no adult would have chosen is not valuable only if it eventually contributes to a capable adult.
It was part of a life.
Perhaps preparing children for adulthood has occupied so much of our thinking because the future frightens us. We know we cannot control what will happen to them, so we try to give them everything we imagine they might need before they get there.
But childhood cannot guarantee adulthood. No collection of experiences, skills, achievements, or carefully managed opportunities can do that.
What we can know is much simpler.
This particular childhood is happening now.
It will be shaped partly by circumstances none of us can control and partly by the decisions adults make on children's behalf. It will contain frustration, disappointment, conflict, limits, and things we wish we could protect them from. There is no way to manufacture a perfect childhood, any more than there is a way to manufacture a perfect future.
But perhaps we can resist asking childhood to spend quite so much of itself proving that it is leading somewhere worthwhile.
Children are growing toward adulthood.
They are also people now.
And the years before they grow up don't need to justify themselves by what comes afterward.
Want to Explore More?
If this article has you thinking about what happens inside you when your child isn't following the path you expected, our Parenting Archetype Quiz can help you explore the fears, expectations, and patterns that tend to surface when parenting feels uncertain.
→ Take the Parenting Archetype Quiz
Have a question about homeschooling, unschooling, parenting, or relationships that you keep turning over in your mind? Send it to Dear Sari & Becka. We choose one reader question each week and respond together.
→ Ask your anonymous question to Sari & Becka
You may also enjoy:
→ What Happens When We Treat Children Like Projects?
→ Will My Child Be Okay? Why Parenting Can Never Come With Guarantees
Listen to the Conversation
This article was inspired by our Radical Learning Talks episode The Essence of Childhood, where we explore childhood, adult expectations, fear, freedom, and what it can mean to let children have a childhood that belongs to them.
Listen to the episode:
